|
Sex, Nursery
Rhymes and Other Evils:
A Look at the Bizarre,
Amusing, Sometimes Shocking Advice of Victorian Childcare Experts
Dr.
Marshall's third book recounts unusual, strange and sometimes downright
dangerous advice that childcare 'experts' gave to parents in Victorian
times. Moral dangers were attributed to bicycle riding. In some circumstances,
learning nursery rhymes was considered evil. While these admonitions and
others seem humourous by today's standards, there is a sinister side to
this issue. At times, parenting advice threatened children’s health, if
not their lives. In other cases, experts' guidance spoke to motives far
removed from child welfare: economic gain, political power, and the suppression
of women were the cultural subtexts that informed experts' thinking.
An interesting
and enlightening review of parenting literature, Sex, Nursery Rhymes and
Other Evils is also a cautionary tale for our times. In the final section,
Dr. Marshall addresses the modern-day interest in child care and parenting
as a 'profession:' How much has changed since Victorian times? Is professional
advice to be trusted or is it based more on personal bias and untested
assumption than it is on fact? How expert are the experts?
Dr.
Marshall concludes that there should be greater responsibility and accountability
among those who have the opportunity to offer advice. Above all, experts
must strive to be their own toughest critics - and parents, in considering
professional advice, should trust their common sense and their own best
judgement.
|
|